So, you want to know who plays Lizzie Borden? No, not the axe-wielding ghost. I mean the person. The actor. The poor soul who has to carry a prop hatchet and look dreamy while being accused of murder. It’s a surprisingly long and juicy list.

First up: Christina Ricci. She owns the modern version. In the 2014 TV movie Lizzie Borden Took an Ax, she is all simmering rage and silent stares. She doesn’t just swing the axe; she feels it. Ricci made Lizzie weirdly relatable. You almost root for her. Almost.

Then there’s Chloë Sevigny. She took the role in 2015 for The Lizzie Borden Chronicles (the sequel TV series). Her Lizzie is a fashion plate with a murderous hobby. Sevigny played her like a gothic queen who has terrible taste in neighbors. She wore stunning corsets while hiding bloodstains. Iconic.

But wait—let’s go old school. Elizabeth Montgomery. Yes, Samantha from Bewitched. In 1975, she played Lizzie in a TV movie The Legend of Lizzie Borden. She didn’t use witchcraft. She used a hatchet. Montgomery’s performance was so intense, it made Bewitched re-runs feel terrifying. You’ll never see a nose-twitch the same way.

Don’t forget the stage.

The musical Lizzie is a thing. Yes, a rock musical. It casts four women as Lizzie, Bridget the maid, Emma the sister, and Mrs. Borden. The performances are loud, chaotic, and full of electric guitars. One actress plays Lizzie screaming about “Thiry days and thirty whacks.” It’s punk rock history.

Another fun fact: Charlotte Gainsbourg played Lizzie in a French film called Happily Ever After (or 42nd E Terrace). It’s very weird. She speaks in French. She looks haunted. It’s the artistic, pretentious Lizzie you bring up at dinner parties.

And then there’s the spoof. In The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror, Marge plays Lizzie. She wears a gray wig and looks fed up. Homer is the dad. The joke is that Marge definitely did it. It’s hilarious because the show once used a real historical murder for a cartoon gag. That’s the power of Lizzie.

Lizzie Borden llegará a Netflix en la cuarta temporada de “Monster”Lizzie Borden llegará a Netflix en la cuarta temporada de “Monster”

Why do so many actresses want this role?

Because it’s the ultimate bad girl role. She’s innocent until proven guilty. Or she’s guilty and clever. Every actress gets to decide. You can play her as a victim of abuse. You can play her as a cold psychopath. Or you can play her as a woman who just really needed a nap.

The hatchet is a prop. The real weapon is the performance. Every actress brings her own weird spin. Christina Ricci chews on her lines like they’re last night’s roast beef. Chloë Sevigny glares like you stole her last teacup. Elizabeth Montgomery looks like she’s about to bake a casserole and then ruin your life.

There’s even a parody podcast called The Lizzie Bennet Diaries that is not about murder. But people confuse it with Lizzie Borden all the time. Imagine a Jane Austen character who talks about axes. That’s the internet for you.

The weirdest casting? Let’s discuss.

Lindsay Lohan once signed on to play Lizzie in a movie called Lizzie Borden: The Legend. It never got made. But imagine the headlines. “Lindsay Lohan, Axe-cessory to Murder.” It would have been a wild ride. Sadly, we’ll never know.

Japanese actress Ai Hashimoto played Lizzie in a stage production in Tokyo. She wore a kimono. She spoke Japanese. The axe was a wooden practice sword. It was cultural appropriation plus period drama. Weird, right? But the crowd loved it.

The cast of Monster: Lizzie Borden and the people they playThe cast of Monster: Lizzie Borden and the people they play

And in the 2023 indie film A Cowboy and Lizzie, a man in drag played Lizzie. Yes. A cowboy hat, a beard, and a checkered dress. He later reveals that the hatchet is a toy. The film is on YouTube. Don’t watch it sober. You’ll laugh at history.

The big question: Who is the best Lizzie?

That’s like asking which flavor of scream is the loudest. Christina Ricci is the moody queen. Chloë Sevigny is the glamorous killer. Elizabeth Montgomery is the OG. None of them are the real Lizzie—but that’s the fun. The real Lizzie is a blank slate. A woman in a photograph with a strange haircut. We project our weirdness onto her.

So next time you watch a Lizzie Borden movie, shout at the screen. “You’re doing it wrong! She would wear blue!” That’s the joy. Every actor gives you a new puzzle piece. You get to decide if she’s a monster, a martyr, or just a very bad cook.

The best part? No one has ever played her exactly right. Because no one knows the truth. The hatchet remains wet. The performances keep coming. And we keep watching, grinning, asking the same old question: Did she do it? The real answer is: Who cares? The acting is the real crime scene.

Now go watch a clip. Then ask your friends. “Who played Lizzie Borden?” Watch them argue. It’s better than reality TV. It’s history with a side of ham.