So, picture this: it’s a Saturday night, I’m three glasses of wine in, and my friend leans over to whisper, “Okay, but who actually are these judges? Like, do they have real jobs?” I laughed, then realized—I had no idea. I mean, I knew they were scary (looking at you, Craig) or lovely (hello, Anton), but their actual lives? A mystery. So, let’s fix that. Grab a cuppa, and let’s unmask the four faces behind the scoring paddles.
The Head Judge: Shirley Ballas
Shirley Ballas is the Queen of Latin—literally. Before Strictly, she dominated the world of ballroom dancing, winning over 20 major championships. She’s known as “The Queen of Latin” because she taught the art of the samba, not just the steps.
But here’s the juicy bit: she took over from Len Goodman in 2017. That’s like replacing your favourite granddad—no pressure, right? Shirley brings a dancer’s eye for technique, often critiquing the “toe-turns” and “hip action” that the rest of us miss.
Must Read
She’s also a mum to a champion dancer, Mark, which explains why she’s so strict. Honestly, if I had a son who won the British Championships, I’d be a bit of a perfectionist too. Friendly side note: next time she gives a 5, just remember—she’s comparing them to world-class talent.
Craig Revel Horwood: The Villain We Love
Craig is the judge you love to hate, but secretly—adore. He’s been on the panel since day one (2004), and he’s never, ever held back. His catchphrase? “Dah-ling, it was a bit dis-ah-ster.” He delivers it with such theatrical flair, you almost forget he’s crushing someone’s dream.
Before Strictly, Craig was a professional dancer and choreographer in musical theatre. He’s worked on West End shows like Miss Saigon and Chicago. So when he moans about “lack of performance,” he knows exactly what he’s talking about.
But here’s the twist: off-camera, he’s genuinely kind. He runs a charity for young dancers and has a dry sense of humour. Just don’t expect a 10 from him. Ever. He’s the reason you feel both offended and entertained at the same time.
Strictly Come Dancing judges Anton, Shirley, Motsi and Craig on their
Motsi Mabuse: The Energy Queen
Motsi joined in 2019, and she was the fresh energy the panel needed. She’s a South African-born professional dancer who won Let’s Dance (Germany’s version of Strictly) multiple times. Yes, she’s also the big sister of Oti Mabuse, so dancing runs in the blood.
What makes Motsi special is her emotional connection. She doesn’t just score—she feels. You’ll see her tearing up during a beautiful waltz or jumping out of her seat for a samba. Side note: She’s the only judge who consistently wears outfits that look like they escaped from a disco ball.
She’s also a trained ballroom expert, so her critiques are sharp but wrapped in a hug. When she says, “You need to connect with the music,” she means it—because she’s lived it. Plus, she’s German-based, so her accent adds a certain flair to any critique.
Anton Du Beke: The Gentleman (and Joker)
Anton is the newest full-time judge, but he’s been part of Strictly since the first series a a professional dancer. For years, he was the “nice guy” who never won, always getting partners who couldn’t dance (like Ann Widdecombe). That tragedy is now comedy gold.
Judges revealed for 2022 series of Strictly Come Dancing - Media Centre
When he replaced Bruno Tonioli in 2021, fans were nervous. But Anton brought something fresh: gentle humour and a dancer’s soul. He knows what it’s like to be a contestant under the judges’ spotlight, so his comments are often empathetic. Like, “It wasn’t perfect, but I saw the effort, darling.”
He’s also a published author and a caviar-loving dandy. But don’t be fooled—he can be sharp. If you mess up the foxtrot, Anton will call you out on the “posture” and “frame.” He just does it without making you cry. Honestly, he’s the judge you’d want to have a pint with.
So, Why Do They Judge So Differently?
That’s the magic of the panel. Craig is the technical purist, Shirley the perfectionist, Motsi the emotional soul, and Anton the forgiving friend. Together, they create a balance that makes the show addictive. You might not agree with a 6 from Craig, but you’ll still cheer for Motsi’s 9.
Final thought: Next time you watch Strictly, remember that each judge has danced on a world stage. They’re not just being mean—they’re trying to help a celebrity do a perfect rumba. And if they blow a fuse? Well, you can always mute the telly and imagine you’re the fifth judge. You know you’ve done it.